I just got my ncoer today which I had to sign with no input due to the whole unit being gone for training. My big thing is my first line supervisor gave me success in every box but PT (due to me failing with no card as proof). As well as good bullets(almost tempted to be excellents in some) Now with that said both my senior rater and rater both rated me as marginal with 4 blocks. Dont they rate based on the ncoer? How can I have good bullets and a bad rating? Should I appeal? Thanks in advance for any advice.